help me pick out the fabrics for my chairs

Chair before coloring incident

I have a set of chairs in the living that I was covering in Amy Butler fabric. The chairs were such a pain to redo, that I did one of them and have been procrastinating on the other. I bought the fabric awhile ago, and they don't have it in my fabric store anymore, although I suppose I could track it down on the net somewhere.

Current fabric on arm chairs: Amy Butler nickel & primrose, shown above

Sadly, the chair that I did have completed has been decorated with red crayon by our 2 year old, Bowie.

I have a few options:

(1) Try like hell to get the crayon out with a Magic Eraser, and recover the other chair in the remaining Amy Butler fabric to match

(2) Crayon doesn't come out, recover both chairs in new fabric

(3) Crayon comes out, recover both chairs in new fabric anyway.

Impacts on this decision:

(1) I plan to make a slipcover for my Queen Anne-style sofa in dropcloth material. It will make the formal looking sofa a lot less fussy, and protect it from the kids and pets a bit.

(2) Steven's comfy chair will need to be recovered.

Steven's ugly comfy chair (shown in storage)

Now... I want to recover Steven's comfy chair in something bright and contrasting. Like this $1300 chair from Anthropology:

With the current Amy Butler fabric, this chocolate brown Alexander Henry might be enough of a punch to not be obnoxious, and compliment the drop cloth covered sofa:

Or, this bright pink Joel Dewberry could bring in the pink that I love so much (not sure how it will jive with the Amy Butler though):


Or, I could use the above Joel Dewberry for the comfy chair, and recover the pair of chairs in this Joel Dewberry that I am not 100% in love with but it matches:

There is also this Amy Butler (that would have to be ordered) that has pink in it... but I worry about having too much green in the room. I like how the original one I used has blue in it.

I like the look of the green and blue fabric against my light sagey green walls. Right now, I am thinking:

(1) Scrub out crayon on tainted chair. (I said taint!) Order more fabric if it doesn't come out in the same color. Recover second chair.

(2) Recover comfy chair in either chocolate Alexander Henry or bright pink Joel Dewberry.

I am seeking suggestions here, folks. What do you think?